GONUTS has been updated to MW1.31 Most things seem to be working but be sure to report problems.

Have any questions? Please email us at ecoliwiki@gmail.com

Cacao

Jump to: navigation, search
GO:0050421nitrite reductase (NO-forming) activityPMID:9023961IMP: Inferred from Mutant Phenotype F
This annotation made on page: CUPNE:Q44012
By: Bionzc (group Team Denitrifiers) on 2011-10-22 13:32:16 CDT.




You must be logged in to challenge this annotation.

Entry TypeChallenging User,GroupTime/DateChallenge ReasonPoints/Assessment
ChallengeBionzc,
Team Denitrifiers
2011-10-29 11:44:18 CDT

Figure 3: The first sentence of the figure is “Nitrite-reducing properties of the NirS mutant HF384 grown anaer- obically on nitrate.” No where in the figure does it mention NarG or NapF. Maybe it would have been clearer if I originally worded my explanation this way: both the wild type, and mutant NirS genes were grown of nitrate. Both the wild type and the mutant was able to convert the nitrate to nitrite. However, the wild type NirS were able to reduce the nitrate into nitrogen oxidizes, while the NirS mutants could not. Because of this, nitrite built up in the medium. You can see this by looking at the figure. The black squares represented by the black squares and you can see a reduction of nitrite over time. On the other hand, the white triangles represent the NirS mutants and you can see a increase in nitrite over time since the mutants are unable to further reduce nitrite to nitrogen oxides.

5
ChallengeLrodgers,
Team KremlinOnTheCrum
2011-10-25 21:38:26 CDT

Figure 3 does not talk about the mechanism by which nitrite is accumulated in the medium based on the conversion of nitrate to nitrite. Instead this figure shows that when external nitrite is added there is an increase in the genes narG and napF. There is no mention of nirS in this figure.



0
Public
Assessment
Bmcintosh2011-11-18 11:12:57 CST

We agree with the rebuttal submitted by the originally authoring team.

Acceptable